| NAME | GENDER | BREED | COLOR | HEIGHT | ABILITIES | PLAYER |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Owlyn | Female | Mustang | Gray and White Overo | 15.1 hh | Water II | Emily |
| Pacino | Male | Andalusian Hybrid | Bay Tobiano (Ee/Aa/nT) | 17.2 hh | Fire II | Elvin |
| Paddington | Male | Welsh Pony:Section A | Grey | 11.2 hh | Earth III | Squeezie |
| Paelos | Female | Appaloosa | Brown Blanket Appaloosa | 16.0 hh | Water I | Abagail26 |
| Pallas Athene | Female | Arabian/Warmblood | Chestnut | 16 hh | Water I | Sabella |
| Pan | Male | Friesian | Unknown | Unknown | Darkness I | Aznarin |
| Pandora | Female | Hybrid | Unknown | Unknown | Fire I | Firenze |
| Pandyra | Female | Orlov Trotter | Dappled Grey | 16 hh | Air II | October |
| Panini | Male | Hybrid | Chestnut | 16.3 hh | Fire I, Twin to Ceres, Mild Myopia (Nearsighted) | Obsidian |
| Pantomime | Female | Hybrid | Bay Roan | Unknown | Earth II | Kesera |
| Paparazzi | Male | Anglo Arabian / Foxtrotter | Blue W/ Reverse Lavender Brindling | Unknown | Psychic II | Piff |
| Paramour | Female | Thoroughbred Hybrid | Bay | Unknown | Electricity III, Twin to Charon, Can control twin's elements | M&M |
| Paris | Female | Selle Francaise | Dark Bay | 15.3 hh | Earth II | Echo |
| Parody | Male | Andalusian/Knabstrup | Black | Unknown | Electricity I | Shazzi Puppy |
| Passion | Female | Arabian | Palomino | 15.2 hh | None | Shenan |
| Patrick | Male | Azteca | Cremello | 15 hh | Psychic II | Demon Pictce |
| Paura | Female | Friesian | Black | 16 hh | Electricity I | Madeline |
| Pazuzu | Female | Akhal Teke Hybrid | Buckskin Splash | Unknown | None | Zombie |
| Pencey Prep | Male | Welara | Bay | 13 hh | Fire II | Livv |
| Penneywise | Male | Hybrid | Chestnut Tobiano | 15 hh | Fire I | M&M |