| NAME | GENDER | BREED | COLOR | HEIGHT | ABILITIES | PLAYER |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pennywise | Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | None | shroominator |
| Peppermint | Male | Hybrid | Palomino Roan | 15.2 hh | Earth I, Blind | Kcat |
| Perdita | Female | Anglo Arabian | Grey w/ black markings | 15.5 hh | Water II | JJ |
| Persephone | Female | Arabian | Unknown | Unknown | Darkness II | Pharise |
| Perverse | Female | Missouri Foxtrotter | Black Tobiano | 15.1 hh | Psychic III | ZG |
| Perversion | Male | Hybrid | Bay | 17.2 hh | Earth II | Mia |
| Phaeton | Male | Mustang | Buckskin Tobiano | 14.3 hh | Psychic I | Sazaki |
| Phantom of the Opera | Male | Arabian/Gypsy Vanner | Black Tobiano | 15.1 hh | Light I | Terris |
| Philomel | Female | Welsh x Draft Hybrid | Smokey Black Tobiano | 15 hh | Light I | Gale |
| Phoenix | Female | Friesian Hybrid | Black | Unknown | Earth II | Rain |
| Phoenixx | Male | Draft Hybrid | Black | 18 hh | Fire I | Zombie |
| Pierce | Female | Grade | Dark Bay | 16 hh | Darkness I | Chaos |
| Pilgrim | Female | Arabian | Unknown | Unknown | Water I | Summer |
| Pine Marten | Male | Paint | White | 15.2 hh | Earth I, Brown and Gray Spots | Kiba |
| Pinkly Smooth | Male | Oldenburg Hybrid | Buckskin | 15 hh | Electricity I | Livv |
| Pirate | Female | Paint | Palomino | 15.1 hh | Light I | Jen |
| Pizazz | Male | Hybrid | Silver Black Sabino | 16.1 hh | Earth I, Hears voices | Judith |
| Pizzaz | Male | Hybrid | Silver Black Sabino | 16.1 hh | Earth I, Hears Voices (moderate) | Judith |
| Plans | Female | Warlander/Appendix Quarter Horse | Grey | 17 hh | Air I | Brandy |
| Poe | Female | Friesian | Black | 16 hh | Electricity I | Monroe |