| NAME | GENDER | BREED | COLOR | HEIGHT | ABILITIES | PLAYER |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Poison | Female | Paso Fino / Pintabian | Grey Overo | 14.3 hh | Electricity I, | Wolfy |
| Poker Face | Male | Andalusian Hybrid | Silver Dun | 17 hh | Fire I | Rashnu |
| Polterchrist | Genderless | Hybrid | Albino | 14 hh | Twin to Prometheus, Can speak psychially to twin | Livv |
| Poltergeist | Female | Hybrid | Black | 15.1 hh | Earth II, Crippled wings, Cannibalistic, Missing one ear, Psychotic Delusions | Gemma |
| Polyxena | Female | Azteca | Black | 15.1 hh | Water I | Chimera |
| Portia | Female | Friesian/Arabian | True Black | 16.2 hh | Psychic V | Nicole |
| Poseidon | Female | Paint | Unknown | Unknown | Psychic I | Firenze |
| Priest | Male | Bashkir Curly | Bay Tobiano | 16 hh | Darkness IV | Syd |
| Primonetta | Female | Lusitano Hybrid | Grey (chestnut Base) | 15.1 hh | Water IV, Earth IV, Light III, Commune With Living Things, Shapeshift Night Fury Dragon | Julz |
| Princess of the Darkness | Female | Mustang | Unknown | Unknown | None | Unknown |
| Prodigy | Male | Hanoverian | Blood Chestnut | 16.1 hh | Fire I | Sparten |
| Prometheus | Genderless | Hybrid | Albino | Unknown | Twin to Polterchrist, Speak psychically to twin | Jett |
| Prophet | Male | Andalusian | Black | 16 hh | Air I, Blind in left eye | Calhal |
| Puck | Male | Hybrid | Black w/ blue and white bridle | Unknown | Disappearing wings, fangs, carnivore, tiny spikes along outside of left eye, slitted blue eyes | Monroe |
| Punk | Male | Lusitano | Unknown | Unknown | Earth I | Candy |
| Puzzle | Male | Hybrid | Blue Black Leopard | 16 hh | Water I, Ranidaphobia | Judith |
| Puzzle | Male | Hybrid | Blue Black Leopard | 16.0 hh | Water I, Severe Ranidaphobia (fear of frogs) | Judith |
| Puzzle Pieces | Female | Anglo Arabian | Unknown | Unknown | Earth I | Muffin |
| Pyromaniac's Fire | Female | Ardennes | Grey | 16 hh | Electricity I | 777 |
| Pythius | Male | Hybrid | Buckskin | 16.2 hh | Darkness I | Jett |